Looking for a quick dinner idea the whole family will love? Try these Blackstone Pizza Sandwiches! Meltely cheese, sauce, your favorite pizza toppings, all between two slices of perfectly toasted bread! It’s perfect for busy weeknights when you want something delicious but don’t have hours to spend in the kitchen. With just a few simple ingredients and minimal prep time, you can satisfy your pizza cravings in no time.

This is not your ordinary sandwich – it’s a flavor explosion that will leave you craving more. Whether you’re looking for a quick and easy lunch option or a satisfying dinner idea that even the kids will eat, this Pizza Sandwich is sure to hit the spot.

What I love about these Blackstone Sandwiches

Easy dinner for the adults and kids
Just 6 ingredients
Comes together effortlessly on the flat top or Blackstone grill.
Dinner can be served in about 10 minutes!

I love some hot sandwiches done on the Blackstone griddle (or the Traeger Flatrock). Especially on hot Summer nights when nothing else sounds good. Last year we made some Grilled Chicken Parmesan Sandwiches which were a hit. I looked in the freezer and saw some pizza flavored sausage from our butcher (yes it’s as amazing as it sounds). And got to thinking what I could make with it. We always have stuff to make pizzas here so I decided to turn them into some toasty sandwiches. WIN! Basically a pizza version of grilled cheese….yum times 2.

Ingredients needed for these Blackstone Pizza Sandwiches

🍕Italian Sausage- I actually had pizza flavored sausage from a local butcher which was great but Italian sausage or even zesty breakfast sausage will work!

🍕Pepperoni- regular or turkey pepperoni works just fine.

🍕Italian Bread – Or your favorite bread for toasting.

🍕Pizza Sauce– I just bought store brand for even marinara works.

🍕 Mozzarella– I like shredded mozzarella or an Italian blend for these. You could also use slices for less mess.

🍕Butter– I added a little butter where I was toasting the bread.

Need some new griddle accessories? Check out this basic 5 piece set on amazon!

Step-by-step tips on making the perfect Pizza Sandwich

Step 1: Fire the flat top up and lightly add oil if needed. (We usually clean it after each use and do it then so its’ read for next time. Plus you have grease from the sausage and pepperoni so you don’t need a lot. Add on the sausage and pepperoni and let cook for a few minutes until browned and no longer pink.

Step 2: When the sausage is almost done, add some butter to the other side of the surface (set to low) and add the Italian bread. On one slice add the pizza sauce, on the other add some cheese. Let toast and melt for a few minutes.

Step 3: When everything is cooked to your liking, load the slices of bread with the sausage and pepperoni mixture. Then top with the other slice of bread.

Variations and substitutions for these Pizzas Sandwiches

You can always opt for sourdough, whole wheat, or a multi-grain bread.
Want to add some veggies? Some green peppers, onions, mushrooms, jalapeños, or olives would be great choices- basically whatever your favorite pizza toppings are-go for it!
Want it meaty? Add some bacon!

Looking for more griddle sandwiches? Check out my:

Make sure to Pin It!